Cast[]
| Singles/OG's | OG Show | Exes | OG Show |
|---|---|---|---|
| Zak Jones | Are You The One? 7 | Morgan Fletcher | Are You The One? 7 |
| Shanley McIntee | Are You The One? 1 | ||
| Kaitlyn Herman | Big Brother 20 | Joe Pincus | N/A |
| Sarah Oliver | Bad Girls Club: Miami | Jimmy "Inkman" Coney | N/A |
| Derek Kesseler | Big Brother Canada 6 | Kaela Grant | Big Brother Canada 6 |
| Devin Walker | Are You The One? 3 | Kiki Cooper | Are You The One? 3 |
| Camila Nakagawa | Spring Break Challenge | ||
| Alivia Hunter | Are You The One? 6 | Kareem Fathalla | Are You The One? 6 |
| Nilsa Prowant | Floribama Shore | Gus Smyrnious | Floribama Shore |
| Matt Clines | Big Brother 19 | Raven Walton | Big Brother 19 |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | RW: Key West | Nany Gonzalez | RW: Las Vegas (2011) |
| Natalie Negrotti | Big Brother 18 | ||
| Angela Babicz | Bad Girls Club: Twisted Sisters | Hector Garcia | N/A |
| [A] Winston Hines | Big Brother 20 | N/A | |
| [A] Kara Kay | Survivor: David vs Goliath | Dan Rengering | Survivor: David vs Goliath |
| [B] Mark Jansen | Big Brother 19 | Elena Davies | Big Brother 19 |
[A] Person arrived in the 3rd episode as a temptation and a new Single
[B] Person arrived in the 5th episode as a new Single