| Champions | Finish | |
|---|---|---|
 |
Camila Nakagawa Spring Break Challenge |
Runner Up |
 |
Hunter Barfield AYTO? 3 |
Runner Up |
 |
Rachel Campos RR: Campus Crawl |
Runner Up |
 |
Sarah Rice RW: Brooklyn |
Runner Up |
 |
Wes Bergmann RW: Austin |
Runner Up |
 |
Zach Nichols RW: San Diego (2010) |
Runner Up |
 |
Cara Maria Sorbello Fresh Meat II |
Episode 10 |
 |
Chris "CT" Tamberuello RW: Paris | |
 |
Jordan Wiseley RW: Portland |
Episode 9 |
 |
Darrell Taylor RR: Campus Crawl |
Episode 8 |
 |
Dee Nyugen Geordie Shore |
Episode 6 |
 |
Rogan O'Connor Ex on the Beach UK 2 |
Episode 4 |
 |
Tori Hall RR: Viewer's Revenge |
Episode 3 |
 |
Veronica Portillo RR: Summer at Sea |
Episode 2 |
 |
Johnnny "Bananas" Devenanzio RW: Key West |
Episode 1 |
 |
Laurel Stucky Fresh Maet II | |
| Challengers | Finish | |
|---|---|---|
 |
Aneesa Ferriera RW: Chicago |
Winner |
 |
Georgia Harrison Love Island UK 3 |
Winner |
 |
Joss Mooney Ex on the Beach UK 1 |
Winner |
 |
Nelson Thomas AYTO? 3 |
Winner |
 |
Tony Raines RW: Skeletons |
Winner |
 |
Tori Deal AYTO? 4 |
Winner |
 |
KellyAnne Judd RW: Sydney |
Episode 9 |
 |
Kam Williams AYTO? 5 |
Episode 8 |
 |
Paulie Calafiore Big Brother 18 |
Episode 7 |
 |
Jenna Compono RW: Ex-Plosion | |
 |
Shane Landruum RR: Campus Crawl |
Episode 6 |
 |
Theo Campbell Love Island Uk 3 |
Episode 5 |
 |
Da'Vonne Rogers Big Brother 17 | |
 |
Nany Gonzalez RW: Las Vegas (2011) |
Episode 4 |
 |
Leroy Garrett RW: Las Vegas (2011) |
Epsiode 3 |
 |
Kyle Christie Geordie Shore |
Episode 2 |
| Episode | Winner | Pit Contestants | Pit Game | Pit Outcome | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Champions | Challenger |
Winner |
Loser | |||||||
| 1 | Challengera | Bananas | Laurel | Leroy | Georgia | Wrecking Wall | Leroy | Georgia | Bananas | Leroy |
| 2 | Champions | Hunter | Veronica | Kyle | Da'Vonne | Balls In | Hunter | Da'Vonne | Kyle | Veronica |
| 3 | Challengers | Ct | Tori H | Leroy | Jenna | Pole Wrestle | CT | Jenna | Leroy | Tori H |
| 4 | Champions | Rogan | Cara Maria | Paulie | Nany | Hall Brawl | Paulie | Cara Maria | Rogan | Nany |
| 5 | Challengers | Wes | Cara Maria | Theo | Da'Vone | Wall Buster | Wes | Cara Maria | Theo | Da'Vonne |
| 6 | Champions | HUnter | Dee | Shane | Georgia | Stacked | Hunter | Georgia | Shane | Dee |
| 7 | Champions | Jordan | Cara Maria | Paulie | Jenna | Knot So Fast | Jordan | Cara Maria | Paulie | Jenna |
| 8 | Champions | Darrell | Camila | Joss | Kam | Tagged | Joss | Camila | Darrell | Kam |
| 9 | Champions | Jordan | Rachel | Tony | KellyAnne | Back Up Off Me | Tony | Rachel | Jordan | KellyAnne |
| 10 | Challengers | CT | Cara Maria | Nelson | Georgia | Puzzle Pyramid | Nelson | Georgia | CT | Cara Maria |
| Finale | 1st; Challengers 2nd; Champions | |||||||||
| Female Contestants | Episode | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | Final | |
| Aneesa | win | safe | win | safe | win | safe | safe | safe | safe | win | WINNER |
| Georgia | pit | safe | win | safe | win | pit | safe | safe | safe | pit | WINNER |
| Tori D | win | safe | win | safe | win | safe | safe | sfae | safe | win | WINNER |
| Camila | safe | win | safe | win | safe | win | win | pit | win | safe | Runner Up |
| Rachel | safe | win | safe | win | safe | win | win | win | pit | safe | Runner up |
| Sarah | safe | win | safe | win | safe | win | win | win | win | safe | Runner Up |
| Cara Maria | safe | win | safe | pit | pit | win | pit | win | win | out | |
| KellyAnne | win | safe | win | safe | win | safe | safe | safe | out | ||
| Kam | win | safe | win | safe | win | safe | safe | out | |||
| Jenna | win | safe | pit | safe | win | safe | out | ||||
| Dee | safe | win | safe | win | safe | out | |||||
| Da'Vonne | win | pit | win | safe | out | ||||||
| Nany | win | safe | win | out | |||||||
| Tori H | safe | win | out | ||||||||
| Veronica | safe | out | |||||||||
| Laurel | out | ||||||||||