| Male Competitors | Original Season | Episode | Female Competitors | Original Season | Episode |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Darrell Taylor | RR: Summer at Sea | Winner | Janelle Casanave | RW: Key West | Winner |
| Abram Boise | RR: South Pacific | Runner Up | Melinda Sharp | RW: Austin | Runner Up |
| MJ Garrett | RW: Philadelphia | Third Place | Tina Barta | RR: South Pacific | Third Place |
| Brad Fiorenza | RW: San Diego 2004 | Fourth Place | Ayanna Mackins | RR: Summer at Sea | Fourth Place |
| Nehemiah Clarke | RW: Austin | Episode 12 | Aneesa Ferriera | RW: Chicago | Episode 12 |
| Chris "CT" Tamberuello | RW: Paris | Episode 11 | Kendal Darnell | RR: Campus Crawl | Episode 11 |
| Landon Lueck | RW: Philadelphia | Episode 10 | Evelyn Smith | Fresh Meat | Episode 10 |
| Derrick Kosinski | RR: X-Treme | Episode 9 | Beth Stolarczyk | RW: Los Angeles | Episode 9 |
| Mark Long | RR: USA- The First Adventure | Episode 8 | Katie Cooley | RR: The Quest | Episode 8 |
| Wes Bergmann | RW: Austin | Episode 7 | Trishelle Cannatella | RW: Las Vegas 2002 | Episode 7 |
| Alton Williams | RW: Las Vegas 2002 | Episode 6 | Jodi Weatherton | RR: X-Treme | Episode 6 |
| Syrus Yarbrough | RW: Boston | Episode 5 | Veronica Portillo | RR: All Stars | Episode 5 |
| Laterian Wallace | RR: Maxium Velocity Tour | Episode 4 | Casey Cooper | Fresh Meat | Episode 4 |
| Shane Landruum | RR: Summer at Sea | Episode 3 | Rachel Compos | RR: Campus Crawl | Epusode 3 |
| Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio | RW: Key West | Episode 2 | Coral Smith | RW: Back to New York | Episode 2 |
| Yes Duffy | RR: Summer at Sea | Episode 1 | Cynthia Roberts | RW: Miami | Episode 1 |
| Episode | Challenge | Winner | Last Placed | Winners' Selections | Pit Game | Pit Winner | Pit Loser |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ayanna & Derrick | Aneesa & Yes | Cynthis & Wes | Pole Wrestle | Anessa & Wes | Cynthia & Yes | |
| 2 | Darrell & Tina | Aneesa & Nehemiah | Coral & Bananas | Balls In | Aneesa & Nehemiah | Coral & Bananas | |
| 3 | Melinda & MJ | Evelyn & Wes | Rachel & Shane | Knot So Fast | Evelyn & Wes | Rachel & Shane | |
| 4 | Evelyn & Wes | Kendal & Laterian | Brad & Casey | Hall Brawl | Brad & Kendal | Casey & Laterian | |
| 5 | Katie & Mark | Syrus & Veronica | Ayanna & Derrick | Pole Wrestle | Ayanna & Derrick | Syrus & Veronica | |
| 6 | Katie & Mark | Alton & Jodi | Darrell & Tina | I Can | Darrell & Tina | Alton & Jodi | |
| 7 | Ayanna & Derrick | Evelyn & Wes | Landon & Trishelle | Wrecking wall | Evelyn & Landon | Trishelle & Wes | |
| 8 | Janelle & Landon | Nehemiah & Tina | Katie & Mark | Tug-A-War | Nehemiah & Tina | Katie & Mark | |
| 9 | Mj
Evelyn |
Derrick
Beth |
Landon
Janelle |
Balls In | Landon
Janelle |
Derrick
Beth | |
| 10 | MJ
Melinda |
Brad
Ayanna |
Landon
Evelyn |
Pole Wrestle | Brad
Ayanna |
Landon
Evelyn | |
| 11 | Nehemiah
Janelle |
Abram
Melinda |
CT
Kendal |
Wrecking Wall | Abram
Melinda |
CT
Kendal | |
| 12 | MJ
Melinda |
Darrell
Janelle |
Nehemiah
Aneesa |
Knot So Fast | Darrell
Janelle |
Nehemiah
Aneesa | |
| Finale | FInal | 1st-
Darrell Janelle |
2nd-
Abram Melinda |
3rd- MJ
Tina |
4th-
Brad Ayanna |