Johnny Reilly
Challenger Profile
Original Series RW: Portland
Born May 4, 1991 (1991-05-04) (age 27)
Hometown West Bridgewater, Massachusetts
Challenge Career
Seasons Free Agents (final)
Battle of the Exes II
Rivals III
Challenge Wins 4
Eliminations 5 (3 wins, 2 losses)
Battle of the Ex-iled 1 (1 loss)
Money Won $35,000
Social Media
Twitter JohnnyReilly_
Instagram _johnnyreilly


Retrieved from

The youngest player in the house, newly single Johnny is heartbroken after ending his relationship with Real World: Portland, girlfriend Averey. Now, with the help of a hometown alliance, Johnny is ready to let loose and take on Free Agents. Like his former housemate Jordan, Johnny believes his rookie status is a blessing not a curse, "I like the fact that I'm a rookie. Me coming into the game, no one knows how I'm gonna play. So I got that kind of element of surprise still." However, temptation from the ladies in the house might cloud his focus. Johnny admits, "Once I get out of my little shy shell, my persona will probably change." With gas in the tank for days, keep your eye on this newbie—he could end up going the distance.

After falling in love on their season of The Real World: Portland, Averey moved across the country to be with her Boston boy, Johnny. However, when rumors emerged that Averey was cheating, their once red-hot romance burned quickly to the ground. Even though Averey denied any wrongdoing, Johnny ended the relationship two days before leaving to compete on last season's Free Agents. Johnny charges, "As far as I'm concerned, Averey cheated on me." The tables turned when Free Agents aired, and Averey discovered that Johnny hooked up with the sexy veteran, Nany. Averey explains, "He has not even said sorry or admitted it to me. That's what hurts me. After everything that we've been through, you can't even respect me as a person?!" Will Johnny give Averey the closure she needs to trust him? Or will the cracks in their already fragile relationship shatter any chance they have at making it to the Final?

Childish name-calling and screaming dominated Johnny and Jessica's relationship on The Real World: Portland. In fact, Southern belle Jessica is still emotionally scarred from Johnny fat-shaming her repeatedly, revealing, "I was devastated. I don't understand how you can fit that much dick into one personality." Try as he might, Johnny just can't come up with any compliments to describe his new partner, "Plain and simple, everything she does aggravates me. Her voice from across the room pierces my eardrums." If Johnny had his way, he would never speak to Jessica again, but she sees friendship as necessary to their team success. Will the brutally honest Johnny be able to fake-play-nice and convince his partner that he respects her as a competitor? Or will this pair fall apart and resort back to the ugly name-calling of their past?

Free Agents

Challenge History

Episode Challenge Partners Result
1 Out on a Ledge Team Black WIN
2 Auto Body Rally Cara Maria SAFE
3 Bar Crawl Team Zach ELIM
4 Bounce Out Team Red WIN
5 Piggy Back Team Purple WIN
6 Smarty Pants N/A SAFE
7 Sausage Party WIN
8 Hold That Pose Team Johnny SAFE
9 Dug Out Leroy SAFE
10/11 Crossover Devyn SAFE
11/12 Final Challenge Nany SECOND

Money Won: $35,000

Battle of the Exes II

Challenge History

Episode Challenge Partner Result
1 I Got You Babe SAFE
2 Rounding the Bases DOME
3 On Again, Off Again SAFE
4 The Brush Off SAFE
5 Open Arms SAFE
6/7 Don't Forget About Me DOME
7 Are You the One? OUT

Elimination History

Episode Dome Partner Opponents Result
2 Banded Together WIN
6/7 Stacking Up WIN
7 Hooking Up OUT

Battle of the Ex-iled

Episode Ex-ile Partner Opponents Result
7 Take Out OUT

Rivals III

Challenge History

Episode Challenge Partner Result
1/2 Give Me Some Slack JUNGLE
3 Dirty Laundry SAFE
4/5 Out on a Limb OUT

Elimination History

Episode Jungle Partner Opponents Result
2 Back It Up WIN
5 Weight For Me OUT


Battle of the Exes II Cast Members
JordanExes2Icon SarahExes2Icon
LeroyExes2Icon TheresaExes2Icon
JayExes2Icon JennaExes2Icon
BananasExes2Icon NanyExes2Icon
ZachExes2Icon JonnaExes2Icon
JohnnyExes2Icon AvereyExes2Icon
Johnny & Averey
AdamExes2Icon BrittanyExes2Icon
KnightExes2Icon JemmyeExes2Icon
JohnExes2Icon SimoneExes2Icon
CTExes2Icon DiemExes2Icon
ThomasExes2Icon HaileyExes2Icon
DustinExes2Icon JessicaExes2Icon
Finalist (Quit)
Medically Removed
Rivals III Cast Members
BananasRivals3Icon SarahRivals3Icon
VinceRivals3Icon JennaRivals3Icon
DevinRivals3Icon CheyenneRivals3Icon
DarioRivals3Icon NicoleRivals3Icon
WesRivals3Icon NanyRivals3Icon
NateRivals3Icon ChristinaRivals3Icon
CoryRivals3Icon AshleyRivals3Icon
JamieRivals3Icon KellyAnneRivals3Icon
TonyRivals3Icon CamilaRivals3Icon
NelsonRivals3Icon AmandaRivals3Icon
ThomasRivals3Icon SimoneRivals3Icon
JohnnyRivals3Icon JessicaRivals3Icon
Johnny & Jessica
BrandonRivals3Icon BrianaRivals3Icon
LeroyRivals3Icon AvereyRivals3Icon
Medically Removed